World

A-level and GCSE results: Call for urgent review into grading ‘fiasco’

Students take part in a protest in Millennium Square, Leeds, after the government's U-turn on the calculated grades system

Picture copyright
Danny Lawson/PA Media

Picture caption

College students took half in a protest in Leeds after the federal government’s U-turn on the calculated grades system

The schooling secretary has been urged to launch a review into the dealing with of A-level and GCSE outcomes after exams have been cancelled attributable to coronavirus.

A union for schooling leaders, reminiscent of head academics, says it’ll write to Gavin Williamson over the “fiasco”.

Mr Williamson apologised to pupils after reversing how A-levels and GCSEs are graded following widespread uproar.

The Joint Council for {Qualifications} (JCQ) mentioned pupils will get GCSE outcomes on Thursday as deliberate.

The affirmation comes following confusion over how outcomes day would run after the federal government U-turn.

Julie McCulloch, director of coverage on the Affiliation of Faculty and School Leaders (ASCL), mentioned the JCQ’s affirmation can be a “nice aid” to all involved.

The federal government determination to provide A-level and GCSE college students grades estimated by their academics, reasonably than through an algorithm, signifies that tens of hundreds of A-level college students could now have the grades to commerce as much as their first-choice college presents.

It has prompted issues concerning the variety of out there locations, with prime universities warning that college students who now have greater grades might nonetheless be requested to defer if there is no such thing as a house left on their chosen course.

And uncertainty continues for college students because the admissions service, Ucas, and particular person universities have but to be given entry to the upgraded outcomes.

Alistair Jarvis, chief govt of Universities UK, which represents vice-chancellors mentioned issues might come up round problems with “capability, staffing, placements and services – notably with the social distance measures in place”.

Universities minister Michelle Donelan mentioned she wished to make sure any college students who had accepted a “completely different course” than deliberate, on account of being downgraded final week, ought to be capable of “change their thoughts and to reverse that call”.

She mentioned No 10 was working with universities to assist “enhance the capability out there” as a way to “minimise the quantity of scholars that can be trying to defer.”

Evaluation

By Hannah Richardson, BBC schooling reporter

There may be nonetheless doubt as as to whether the schooling system will do proper by the Class of Covid.

Will their chosen universities be capable of accommodate them? Or have they given their diploma place away already? Will they’ve to return again subsequent 12 months and struggle it out with college students who’ve missed much more faculty?

And for the primary time since this ageing schooling journalist can bear in mind, examination boards usually are not holding their ordinary mind-boggling briefing on GCSE outcomes.

So for a while at the very least, there can be no particulars of how the nation has accomplished of their common faculty certificates examinations.

Roll on the beginning of time period – though that is unsure, too.

A whole bunch of hundreds of kids within the UK have had their schooling disrupted by the pandemic after faculties, schools and nurseries have been ordered to close in March – ensuing within the cancellation of all assessments and exams.

The ASCL – which is writing the letter to Mr Williamson – mentioned a review was urgently wanted into “what went flawed” with the grading system.

“This diploma of transparency is critical at a time when public confidence has been badly shaken,” mentioned ASCL common secretary Geoff Barton.

Mr Barton additionally known as on No 10 and Ofqual to place in place a “strong contingency plan” for college students sitting GCSEs and A-levels subsequent summer time within the occasion of additional coronavirus-related disruption.

How Gavin Williamson survived the U-turn

One former Conservative minister mentioned he absolutely expects Gavin Williamson to be moved in any autumn reshuffle – that he has been given a reprieve by Downing Road, not exoneration.

He has to type out the messy problem of getting newly upgraded college students in to universities then the difficult activity of getting pupils in England again to high school subsequent month.

The partial return previous to the summer time wasn’t precisely clean. So if Mr Williamson’s efficiency in these areas falls brief, then his present job is just not protected in the long run.

However there are different the explanation why he hasn’t obtained a ministerial P45.

This isn’t an administration which does resignations. Boris Johnson is loyal to those that are loyal and helpful to him.

Learn extra from Iain right here.

The College and School Union (UCU) and Nationwide Union of College students (NUS) have additionally written to the schooling secretary, urging No 10 to assist college students who’ve missed out on their first-choice programs and calling for monetary assist for the upper schooling sector.

UCU common secretary Jo Grady mentioned employees have been dealing with “insufferable workloads” as a result of fallout over examination outcomes.

She added that “substantial monetary assist” was wanted “so universities can shield all jobs, safely welcome college students and proceed to offer world class educating and analysis”.

And Ms Grady criticised Mr Williamson’s determination to droop a cap on pupil numbers for universities – successfully permitting establishments to simply accept limitless numbers this 12 months – as a result of she mentioned it meant “sure universities can hoover up college students, hitting the funds of different establishments”.

Regardless of the cap being suspended, some universities have mentioned numbers must stay restricted, notably on vocational programs reminiscent of drugs and dentistry.

Ucas was unable to say what number of college students had not been in a position to take up locations attributable to their outcomes being downgraded.

Pupil tales: Frances and Zainab

Picture caption

Each Frances Ramos (left) and Zainab Ali have been left not sure if they’d get their first-choice college locations, regardless of their grades being bumped up

Frances Ramos, 18, from Towcester, Northamptonshire, mentioned she was happy to be given her predicted grades of ABB – up from the BCD she obtained final Thursday.

However she mentioned the U-turn “does really feel like it’s kind of too late” and added: “I type of want the federal government had accomplished this on Thursday.” She is now ready to listen to if her first selection, the College of Liverpool, will settle for her to check this 12 months.

Zainab Ali, 18, from London, additionally thought the federal government ought to have acted sooner. “I feel it is a disgrace. After the injury is completed, that is when they may take motion and I discover it fairly irritating,” she mentioned.

The U-turn ought to now imply Zainab is ready to attend Queen Mary College, London.

  • College students relieved and irritated after A-level U-turn

Earlier, Mr Williamson mentioned he was “extremely sorry for the misery” brought about to pupils.

Mr Williamson mentioned it had been the widespread view of the federal government, exams regulator Ofqual, and the devolved administrations in Wales and Northern Eire – of various political events – that the system in place was extra strong and “considerably higher” than that in Scotland, after an earlier U-turn in Scotland.

However after the discharge of A-level outcomes on Thursday he mentioned it had turn out to be “more and more obvious that there have been too many younger those who fairly merely hadn’t acquired the grade they really deserved”.

Picture copyright
Getty Pictures

Picture caption

Mr Williamson wouldn’t say whether or not he had supplied his resignation to Prime Minister Boris Johnson throughout interviews on Tuesday

Ofqual’s algorithm got here below hearth after information confirmed its downgrading of about 40% of A-level grades in England had affected state faculties greater than personal establishments.

Ministers in England, Northern Eire and Wales all selected Monday – 4 days after A-level outcomes have been issued – to revert to trainer assessed grades reasonably than the algorithm.

  • NI: Meeting recall over examination outcomes to go forward
  • Wales: Examination board chief ‘disillusioned’ by grades U-turn

The U-turn means academics’ assessments may also be used for all GCSE outcomes – besides for any college students for whom the algorithm provides a better grade.

It’s nonetheless unclear what the climbdown will imply for college students taking vocational {qualifications}, together with BTecs, with college students telling BBC Radio 1’s Newsbeat: “We have been forgotten about.”

Mr Williamson mentioned he hoped they’d even be topic to teacher-assessed grades, including that the federal government was working with awarding authorities to make sure this occurred.

Pearson, which awards BTecs, mentioned it was conscious that some college students had skilled a delay in receiving grades however didn’t say what number of have been impacted.

Timeline: Authorities’s altering place

  • 11 August: Gavin Williamson introduced A-level college students would be capable of use their ends in mock checks to attraction if they’re sad with the grades they’re given, calling it a “security web”. Earlier within the day Scotland’s authorities determined to modify to academics’ predicted grades
  • 12 August: Nick Gibb, faculties minister for England, acknowledged the federal government was “involved” about what had occurred in Scotland however insisted the system in England remained “strong”
  • Thursday 13 August (outcomes day): Mr Williamson dominated out following the Scottish authorities in reversing place, telling Sky Information: “You have to have a system that has checks and balances”. Prime Minister Boris Johnson mentioned the outcomes have been a “strong set of grades”
  • Saturday: Mr Williamson advised the Instances there can be “no U-turn” on the grading system, saying Scotland had ended up with “a system the place there are no controls” and had “rampant grade inflation”
  • Sunday: Mr Williamson defended Ofqual’s grading technique within the Sunday Specific, saying the calculated grade “makes sure that everybody may be assured that these {qualifications} carry the identical weight as earlier years”
  • Monday: Mr Williamson publicizes a transfer to teacher-assessed grades for A-levels and GCSES saying “we now imagine it’s higher”

  • LOCKDOWN LOVE AND TURBO RELATIONSHIPS: How are you dealing with relationship in 2021?
  • ‘MY MENTAL HEALTH CRASHED’: The impression of being turned away from remedy in lockdown


Have your grades been raised? Have you ever nonetheless missed out on a college place? Do you’ve questions on your state of affairs? Get in contact through the shape.

In some circumstances your query can be revealed, displaying your identify, age and location as you present it, until you state in any other case. Your contact particulars won’t ever be revealed. Please guarantee you’ve learn our phrases & circumstances and privateness coverage.

Use this type to ask your query:

If you’re studying this web page and cannot see the shape you have to to go to the cell model of the BBC web site to submit your query or ship them through e-mail to

Source Link

Editorial Team

Passionate news enthusiast with a flair for words. Our Editorial Team author brings you the latest updates, in-depth analysis, and engaging stories. Stay informed with their well-researched articles.

Related Articles

This will close in 5 seconds